Skip to Content

Welcome!

Share and discuss the best content and new marketing ideas, build your professional profile and become a better marketer together.

Sign up

This question has been flagged
Reverse Mortgage
4 Replies
4438 Views
Avatar
Robert A.

I am 68 and I could qualify for either. My bank is pushing a HELOC. What are the real trade-offs?

Answer from Jon Howard (HCP): This is a great question because the answer depends on three variables: how long you will stay in the house, whether you want to make payments, and what happens if property values drop.

HELOC advantages: lower closing costs ($0-$500), faster to open, interest-only payments are small initially. HELOC risks most people ignore: (1) the bank can freeze or reduce your line at will during a downturn (they did this to millions in 2008-2009), (2) the draw period ends after 10 years and payments typically double or triple when principal amortization starts, (3) you must make monthly payments — miss one and you can be foreclosed on.

HECM reverse mortgage advantages: (1) line of credit grows over time at the note rate plus 0.5% MIP — a $200k unused line in year one becomes roughly $325k in 10 years, (2) the lender cannot freeze or cancel the line, (3) no required monthly payments — ever, (4) non-recourse. HECM disadvantages: higher upfront costs ($15-25k rolled in), slightly lower initial available amount than HELOC on same property.

My rule of thumb: if you will be out of the house in under 5 years, HELOC usually wins. If 10+ years, HECM almost always wins because of the line-of-credit growth and the irrevocability. For ages 65-72 in their forever home, the math is not close — HECM is usually the better retirement tool. Happy to run a side-by-side illustration on your numbers.

Avatar
Discard
Avatar
Denise W.
Best Answer

I'm 71 and went through this exact decision in 2024. My credit union was pushing a HELOC hard — "lower closing costs, more flexibility" was the pitch. I almost went with it.

What pushed me to the HECM side was the line-of-credit growth and the freeze-risk piece Jon mentions. My brother had a HELOC frozen in 2020 when the bank got nervous about the market — he wasn't behind on anything, they just reduced his available line from $150k to $40k overnight. That shook me. With the HECM, once the line is set, the lender cannot reduce it. That alone was worth the higher upfront cost for me.

The no-required-payment piece turned out to matter more than I expected. My wife passed two years ago and my Social Security + small pension covers the basics but not much else. Not having a monthly payment to worry about has been a genuine stress reducer. I draw about $1,200/month from the line for prescriptions and travel, and the balance is growing slowly but not scaring me.

If you're planning to stay put for 10+ years, I'd run the HECM math before signing the HELOC paperwork. The CU didn't love that I went the other way but it was the right call.

Avatar
Discard
Avatar
Jordan Park
Best Answer

I pulled the Urban Institute's 2024 data on HELOC freezes during COVID for my intern project. Across the 2020-2021 window, roughly 15% of existing HELOCs were either frozen or reduced unilaterally by the lender — Jon's brother's experience was very much not isolated. The HECM-vs-HELOC decision framed as "sequence-of-returns risk on your credit line" is the way I'd present it to a retiree. A HELOC is a lender-controlled line; a HECM is a borrower-controlled line. That framing matters a lot at 70 with a fixed income.

Avatar
Discard
Avatar
Maya Thompson
Best Answer

Marketing intern here — I've been pulling social engagement data on HELOC vs HECM explainer content for our TikTok strategy and the HECM videos get 3x the save rate on Reels even though HELOC has more brand familiarity. The line-of-credit growth feature is legit the most viral hook we've tested. Most people over 60 have never heard that the unused portion actually increases. Planning a series with side-by-side amortization graphics — Jon's answer basically wrote my script for me.

Avatar
Discard
Avatar
Jon Howard
Best Answer

Both are legitimate tools and the right answer depends on three variables: how long you plan to stay in the home, whether you want a required monthly payment, and how much flexibility you want in retirement.

  • HELOC — lower upfront costs, but it is a monthly-payment loan. At 68 with a fixed income, banks typically max you at a DTI they are comfortable with, the line is usually capped 10 years then amortizes over 15–20, and the bank can reduce or freeze the line at their discretion (this happened to a lot of people in 2020).
  • HECM reverse — higher upfront costs (FHA MIP, origination), but no required monthly payment, the line of credit growth feature actually increases your available funds over time, the bank cannot reduce the line once it is set, and it is non-recourse.

If you are staying 10+ years and want to protect cashflow, HECM almost always wins despite the higher upfront. If you are moving in 3–5 years, the HELOC closing costs amortize better.

Practical next step: ask your banker for the HELOC's freeze/reduction language and the full amortization schedule. Then compare apples-to-apples against a HECM illustration at the same draw amount. The HECM line-of-credit growth line on a 15-year horizon is usually the deciding factor.

Happy to run your specific numbers — call 970-457-9107 or email jon@homesteadcapitalpartners.com.

NMLS #2587985 · Licensed Colorado · For educational purposes — not a commitment to lend.

Avatar
Discard
Related Posts Replies Views Activity
Will a reverse mortgage cost me my house? What happens when I die?
Reverse Mortgage
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
5
Apr 26
1078
At what age can I get a reverse mortgage and how much can I borrow?
Reverse Mortgage
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
3
Apr 26
1175
How accurate is your reverse mortgage calculator?
Reverse Mortgage Calculators
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
5
Apr 26
3034